The returning of the body of British surgeon Abbas Khan after his 'effective murder' by the Syrian authorities, after he was captured entering Syria illegally to offer humanitarian aid is a quickening moment for his family as furiously they demand an inquiry. The death raises questions about how Damascus could do this with impunity and why the Foreign Office did not get involved. The West is desirous of peace, stability and justice (in that order) but, more importantly, is desirous of not getting involved.
It is not the first time that British nationality has had no effect in preventing the death of a citizen of these isles. 13 years before the introduction of passports, with all the alleged protections detailed for the bearer, during the First Anglo-Afghan War, Captain Arthur Conolly was sent on a mission to the Amir of Bokhara (modern Bukhara), Nasrullah Khan, to ask him to hand over the fugitive former Amir of Afghanistan, Dost Muhammad and release his European prisoners, one of whom included Colonel Charles Stoddart, military aide to the British ambassador to Persia, who was himself in Bokhara trying to secure the release of Russian prisoners (and so remove the pretext for a Russian invasion). It was all part of the Great Game but Khan tired of this game, beheading his British prisoners and letting Dost Muhammad escape. It went unpunished as not long after the Army of the Indus was almost entirely annihilated trying to escape from Kabul and thereafter the British were more concerned organising an expedition of retribution against the Afghans, which they did, forcing the Khyber Pass for the first time in history and burning down the Great Bazaar of Kabul. Nasrullah Khan was left unmolested by the British and lived in comfort for another 18 years.
22 years after the unfortunate events in Bokhara, another ruler taking umbrage at the British tried a similar trick. Emperor Theodore of Abyssinia, feeling slighted that no reply had been given him from a letter he sent to Queen Victoria, imprisoned Captain Charles Cameron, Her Britannic Majesty's consul to his court and furthermore had him tortured on the rack and flogged with a hippopotamus hide whip. This approximates to the unbearable conditions that Abbas Khan had too endure for 13 months until his death, suffering repeated beatings and pain and forced to inflict it on other prisoners by the guards. The Foreign Office, which the family of Abbas Khan have criticised for being next-to-useless in securing the release of their son (apparently, it took the intervention of George Galloway to agree safe passage, in vain as it turned out), was at fault here. If only they had sent a puff piece to mollify Emperor Theodore all might have been well. Byron Farwell, author of
Queen Victoria's Little Wars in his account of this episode, describes the Abyssinian emperor as "a madman but the imbecility of the civil servants in the Foreign Office made it difficult to determine who was the more demented." After mislaying or forgetting or struggling for an appopriate reply, the letter lain unanswered, upon Captain Cameron's gaoling, the Foreign Office dug it up but then chose a Turkish Assyriologist, Hormuzd Rassam, to deliver it. He had difficulty in screwing up the courage, taking a year and a half to reach the emperor. He too was locked up for his troubles by Theodore. More bizarrely, upon a subsequent plea from Theodore for skilled workmen, some machinery and a munitions manufacturer, the Foreign Office recruited a civil engineer and half a dozen artisans and they got as far as Massawa on the Eritrean coast (then under Ottoman/Egyptian control) before the British government halted their progress and decided to launch a punitive war instead.
During a House of Commons debate, Foreign Secretary Lord Palmerston delcared, "As the Roman in days of old, held himself free from indignity when he could say
civis Romanus sum, so also a British subject in whatever land he may be, shall feel confident that the watchful eye and strong arm of England will protect him against injustice and wrong." The United Kingdom was at the height of its power relative to the rest of the world and there was a general feeling that should a British person fall into a spell of bother with the local authorities, he should be rescued if need be. In the campaign of 1867-8, the British Empire marched in, intimidated Theodore into releasing his European prisoners and successfully assaulted his fortress headquarters, whereupon he shot himself. Much booty was carried off (many items of which were later returned by King George VI) and the late emperor's ten-year old son was taken in hand and sent to Rugby to be educated (sadly he died eight years later). It was virtually a textbook war while Abyssinia was left in anarchy as minor princes and chiefs battled for supremacy in the power vacuum.
Theoretically, the Britain of 2013 could have done the same in Syria, as were enough money to be committed plus all troops removed from Afghanistan for this purpose (and the use of the French aircraft carrier Charles de Gaulle), Assad's disgruntled army would be driven off and Hezbollah would not have the well-entrenched hills of southern Lebanon into where to retreat. But leaving Syria in more anarchy than already exists would not be in British interests, for unlike in nineteenth century Abyssinia where it didn't matter to Europe, in Syria, al-Qaeda-linked groups would train up jihadists to send back to the West as currently happens in the north of the country (a Somalia-like zone). The Syrians who want a democracy with Islamic inflections are only at a level of 10% military effectiveness in overall rebel power and are being killed by the extremists just as much as they are by Assad and his allies. Essentially Abbas Khan was left to his fate not because the Foreign Office thought he had no-one to blame but himself for going there in the first place but because they now view Assad as the best bet for Syria and felt that they would be only ignored anyway. An early military intervention (in 2011) as in Libya might have worked (of course with the USA providing the bulk of support), though as in north Africa, institutions would be precarious. Now, any attack, even with just cruise missiles will strengthen merely those who reject the West in everything. A political solution is the only option on the table and, however unpalatable, it will involve the wanton killers of women and children. Assad will go down in history as another despot who never personally suffered the consequences of his actions, despite the indictment for war crimes by the International Criminal Court. For Abbas Khan, the lethargic eye and weak arm of England, meant he could not enjoy the protection once afforded to a Roman citizen.